Huck Discussion
Questions: XXI - XXI
1. Through the
Grangerford episode, Twain was able to criticize the myth of Southern honor.
What myth of Southern life does Twain satirize in the Sherburn/Boggs incident
(which, by the way, was based on a true incident)? What aspect of human nature
does Twain satirize through the scene in the drugstore? Compare the circus
with the entertainment supplied by the duke and king?
Twain is making fun of southern honor, and how people were
so obsessed with having honor that they were willing to kill for it. Twain is
mocking how people love seeing terrible things in the drugstore scene. The
circus is quality entertainment at a decent price, while the duke and the
king’s productions are overpriced and a scam. The difference between the two is
that one was created to bring people joy, while the other was created to make
the duke and king money.
2. What does Huck's
reaction to the circus incident tell us about him? Whom does he think was most
deceived?
Huck doesn’t get most jokes, the drunk man in the circus
being one of them. This shows that he is not a very reliable narrator. He
thought the ringmaster was the most deceived.
3. What is Twain
implying about human nature through the advertising for the "Royal
Nonesuch"?
By making the show so that women and children aren’t
permitted, The interest is raised for the men. Twain is implying that people
are captivated by inappropriate things, and are more likely to go see something
provocative instead of something more mild, like a circus.
4. "What was the
use to tell Jim these warn't real kings and dukes? It wouldn't a done no good;
and besides, it was just as I said; you couldn't tell them from the real
kind." (117). What does Twain imply?
Twain is making a joke about royalty, and how sleazy they
are.
5. What is
significant about the story of 'Lizabeth?
In this story, Jim beats his daughter, then realizes she is
deaf. He feels guilty, and misses her dearly. This is significant because it
shows how Jim is a human with a family and has feelings.
Huck Discussion Questions XXIV - XXVII
1. As we have
discussed, clothes can play a symbolic or thematic role in the novel. Huck even
says that he "never knowed how clothes could change a body before."
Discuss the thematic role of clothes in these chapters.
Twain speaks of clothes very often in his novel. Clothes
represent the restriction of society, whilst nakedness is equal to freedom.
2. Comment on the
last paragraph of Chapter XXIV. Make a connection to Twain's description of the
Arkansas town. Why is Huck's response to the Peter Wilks incident so strong?
Why does Huck make moral evaluations now (you'll recall that he remained
morally neutral concerning the prior schemes of the duke and king)?
Huck is beginning to develop basic morals, and is becoming
more human. Huck feels bad about the duke and the king scamming the girls and
pretending to be the brothers of the dead man. Huck realizes these are lovely
girls who don’t deserve to be played like this and is thusly very against this
scheme.
3. What qualities do
the Wilks girls have that allow them to be fooled so easily?
The Wilks girls were very trusting and kind, and believed
everyone was always honest to them.
4. Why is it significant that Joanna eats in
the kitchen? What is the significance of her nickname? What themes are
revealed?
She is disabled so she is forced to eat in the kitchen. Huck calls her harelip, which is basically naming her by her disability. This shows that in this time period, prejudice is a very common part of their lives.
5. What statement
about the behavior of people does Twain make through the Dr. Robinson incident?Tom and Huck saw Dr. Robinson get murdered. They let the blame fall of Muff Potter, not Injun Joe. This shows that people are cowards and will only stand up for others if it benefits themselves.
6. Previously Huck
has refused to hinder the antics of the king and duke. Now he attempts to foil
their scheme. Why? What theme(s) from the novel can you apply to Huck's change
in attitude?
Huck has realized that these girls were actual people with feelings, and
were kind ladies who didn’t deserve to be deceived. This shows Huck is
developing as a character and becoming more human and understanding. The theme
of “the concept of family” is apparent in these chapters. The close-knit family
is something Huck has always been lacking in, and the girls make him feel like
he belongs.
Huck Questions XXVIII - XXX
1. Twain was heavily
criticized for bad taste due to his description of the funeral toward the end
of Chapter XXVII. Why do you think he was criticized, and do you think the
criticism justified?
Funerals have always been a solemn and respectful
environment. I found the killing of the barking dog quite humorous, although I
can see where he would be criticized. People have a tendency to take things too
seriously, funerals included. Anything besides the black, religion-focused norm
and you’re suddenly a terrible person. I’ve always thought funerals were a bit
too serious, and I liked how Twain tweaked what would have been a boring part
of the plot.
2. On page 141 Huck
says, ". . . here's a case where I'm blest if it don't look to me like the
truth is better, and actuly safer, than a lie." Explain.
Huck tells Mary about the duke and the king’s schemes
because he doesn’t think she deserves another person lying to her.
3. In these three
chapters Huck finds himself having to lie for various reasons. How do his
motives differ?
His previous lies were focused around saving himself, whilst his currently
unearthed emotions have made him reanalyze the people around him. Now he is
lying to protect people and prevent the lies of others from hurting the people
he cares about.
4. Why doesn't Twain
involve Jim more in these chapters?
Jim couldn’t really be involved in these chapters because he
is a blue Arab at the moment. Plus, Jim is still seen as a wanted man and it
would be too risky for him to do much of anything, especially when Huck and the
duke and the king are tangled in so many lies.
5. Does Huck's escape from Hines say anything about Hines' character?
Hines’ obsession with the gold shows the corrupt and greedy
nature of society. Hines no longer cares about the imposters or their
“servant,” but more about the idea of riches.
6. How does Huck feel
about Mary Jane? Why does Huck tell her to go away? Significance?
Huck trusts Mary Jane and cares about her. He tells her to
go away because he wants time to come up with a plan to fix things.
7. Discuss the
significance of Huck's statement, ". . . anybody but a lot of prejudiced
chuckleheads would a seen that the old gentlemen was spinning truth and t'other
one lies."
Huck is surprised that no one has caught onto the duke and the king’s lies.
Unfortunately, the family was so enraptured with the unknown uncles coming to
town that they’ll believe anything they’re told.
8. What does the
doctor represent?
The doctor is a strong dosage of realism in a romanticized
world. He has a logical reason to doubt the king and the duke, yet everyone is
so in love with the two men that no one listens to the doctor.
9. By the end of
Chapter XXX, do you think Twain vindicates the characters of the duke and king
or does he have them remain as villains? Explain.
Twain continues to have the duke and the king remain as
villains. They are a sharp contrast to the relatively honest nature of Huck,
and teach the boy that these men are bad.
Huck Discussion Questions XXXI - XXXV
1. Would you say that
Chapter 31 represents the climax of the novel? Why or why not?
I’d say so. Huck finally determines what he wants and where he’s going. He
decides to set himself down a path of unholiness because he believes it is the
right thing to do. He decides his friend is more important than a free ride to
heaven, and is freed by this.
2. Huck says,
"All right, then, I'll go to hell." Explain the irony in that
statement.
This line is the climax of the story. Huck is accepting his
eventual descent into hell for the sake of his friend. Earlier in the story,
Huck had spoken about how he’d rather go to heaven then hell because he would
be with Tom Sawyer. This idea of Huck and hell is reoccurring throughout the
novel.
3. Discuss the
symbolism of the imagery at the beginning of Chapter 32.
The imagery is calm and peaceful, very similar to what Huck
is used to. This is important because Tom Sawyer shows up and Tom is very
familiar to Huck.
4. Discuss Huck's
understanding of Providence (215)? Would Miss Watson agree?
Huck credits Providence for his wits. Miss Watson would disagree because he
is doing wrong and would go straight to hell.
5. How does Twain use
irony in the discussion between Huck and Mrs. Phelps about the "steamboat
accident."
Mrs. Phelps asks if anyone was hurt, and Huck says only a black person had
died. Mrs. Phelps’ relief after hearing this was ironic because at the time, a
black person was nothing more than property. She wasn’t upset because slaves
are more like a renewable resource than an actual human being.
6. One of the
recurring themes becomes apparent when Huck discovers that the Phelps are
expecting Tom Sawyer. Which theme comes to mind and why?
I’d go with Romanticism vs. Reality in this situation. The idea that Tom
would be going to this very plantation was highly improbable, and it would
almost certainly never happen in real life. This is tapping into Twain’s hatred
for romantic literature. Tom is a symbol for adventure-loving romanticists,
which is why I absolutely loathe the boy.
7. Huck and Tom both
agree to help Jim escape; however, their motives are different. Explain.
Huck wants to save his friend, while Tom wanted the adventure.
Tom doesn’t understand that this mission is incredibly dangerous, and thinks of
it as a game of sorts. Huck has experienced the danger firsthand, and is being
incredibly kind by trying to help free his friend.
8. "...and as
they went by I see they had the king and duke astraddle of a rail - that is, I
knowed it WAS the king and the duke, though they was all over tar and feathers.
...Well it made me sick to see it; and I was sorry for them poor pitiful
rascals. ...Human beings CAN be cruel to one another" (225). Comment. What
does this reveal about Huck's character?
In this, the king and the duke are being tarred and feathered as punishment for
their deceptiveness. Huck feels bad for the men, even though they haven’t ever
done anything for him. This shows that Huck is becoming more sympathetic and
kind towards people, even if they don’t deserve it. At the beginning of the
novel, he would have been laughing with the rest of the townspeople.
9. Discuss the irony
in Tom's reaction to the stealing of the watermelon.
Tom has never actually stolen anything because he always left money to pay
for what he “stole.” Tom’s reaction shows how he was a product of society, and
is not like the rebellious nature of Tom’s character that Huck has wanted to
be. It taps into the meaning of family theme. Since Jim is now the property of
Tom’s relatives, Tom thinks it’s alright to steal Jim.
10. Why does Huck let
Tom take control?
Huck knows Tom is very stylistic, and has mentioned his longing for Tom’s
complicated plans many times in earlier chapters. Tom wants control of things
for his on enjoyment, and Huck decides it’s easier to let Tom have his way.